Exploring Afton’s Hidden Gems: Can’t-Miss Spots Just Off the Beaten Path

Here in Afton, some of the best experiences are the ones whispered between locals, passed along like good stories and discovered by travelers willing to take a turn off the main road.

Whether you’re visiting for the first time or you’ve been here a dozen times, these hidden gems offer something a little extra—something you won’t find just anywhere. From natural wonders to quiet lakes, charming farms to scenic lookouts here are a few of Afton’s favorite off-the-beaten-path spots worth exploring.

1. Intermittent Spring – A Natural Wonder That’s Always Changing

While not completely off the radar, the Intermittent Spring still feels like a secret every time you visit. Located just a short five-mile drive from downtown Afton, followed by a scenic half-mile hike, this geological marvel is the largest of only a handful of cold-water geysers in the world.

The spring flows for about 18 minutes, then stops entirely, only to restart again moments later. The trail to the spring is shaded, family-friendly and perfect for nature lovers. Along the way, you’ll hear the rush of Swift Creek, pass through groves of aspen, and likely spot birds, squirrels and maybe even a deer or two.

Bring your water bottles—locals swear the fresh spring water is some of the cleanest, best-tasting you’ll find anywhere. Go early in the morning or in late afternoon for fewer people and the most dramatic lighting.

2. Shumway Farms – A Taste of Star Valley’s Heart

Just outside Afton sits Shumway Farms, a sixth-generation family-owned dairy and creamery that’s been part of Star Valley’s story since 1885. Known for its small-batch, farm-fresh ice cream, Shumway’s creative flavors have become a local favorite. Visitors can stop by the farm store to pick up more than just a scoop; you’ll also find creamy yogurt, raw and pasteurized milk, grass-fed beef, and other locally made goods.

What makes Shumway Farms truly special is the combination of heritage and heart. Using sustainable, regenerative farming practices, the Shumway family continues to craft high-quality dairy products that reflect their deep roots in the valley. The farm store is open Monday through Saturday, making it an easy, delicious stop that connects you to the local flavor of Afton in the most literal sense.

3. Lander Trail Historical Marker & Overlook – A View with a Story

History meets stunning scenery at this lesser-known stop east of Afton. The Lander Trail was a major route used by pioneers heading west in the 1800s, and while it doesn’t get the fame of the Oregon Trail, it played a vital role in settling the region. The historical marker offers context, but the real reward is the panoramic view of Star Valley from the overlook.

It’s an ideal place to stop for a peaceful moment, soak in the sunset, or enjoy a quiet picnic surrounded by whispers of the past. For photographers, the overlook is a goldmine of color and contrast, especially in fall when the valley is painted in reds and golds.

4. Cottonwood Lake – A High-Elevation Hideaway

If you’re willing to venture a little farther and take the scenic route, Cottonwood Lake is one of Afton’s most breathtaking hidden treasures. Nestled deep within the Bridger-Teton National Forest, this alpine lake is perfect for kayaking, paddleboarding, fishing, or just spreading out a blanket and soaking in the mountain views.

Surrounded by towering pine trees and granite peaks, the lake feels untouched and wild. On a calm morning, the water mirrors the sky, and in the late afternoon, the stillness invites quiet reflection. It’s a favorite spot for locals who want to truly disconnect and reconnect with nature.

Access requires a dirt-road drive that can be bumpy, but most vehicles make it just fine—and trust us, the destination is worth the journey.

5. Downtown Afton’s Murals and Art Walk – A Self-Guided Discovery

You may not realize it at first, but Afton has a growing collection of public art woven throughout town. From colorful murals that celebrate our Western heritage to hand-carved statues and small art installations tucked near businesses, exploring downtown becomes a mini scavenger hunt for creativity.

One local favorite is the mural near the Star Valley Chamber of Commerce—a vibrant scene that tells the story of Star Valley’s roots in ranching, community and nature. Grab a coffee or ice cream and take a leisurely walk through town to see how many pieces you can spot.

It’s a great way to experience the town’s personality—and a fun, unexpected addition to any trip itinerary.

Find Your Hidden Story in Afton

Whether you're drawn to quiet trails, clear mountain lakes, or small-town charm, Afton's hidden gems offer a different kind of adventure—the kind where the pace slows down and every turn feels a little more personal.

These spots may not always make the top of the travel guides, but they make a lasting impression on those who take the time to explore them. So come curious, stay a while, and let the quieter side of Star Valley surprise you.